A few weeks after the events of The Killer of Pilgrims, Ralph de Langelee may have a solution to Michaelhouse College's financial problems. Now the Master of Michaelhouse, Langelee was a soldier in service to the late William Zouche, Archbishop of York. A codicil to Zouche's will left a church to Michaelhouse, and now that the incumbent priest has died, Michaelhouse can claim the parish's income. There's a problem, though. No one can find the codicil and the minster's vicars have taken possession of the church. To enforce Michaelhouse's claim, Langelee travels to York with law lecturer John Radford, devious courtier-turned-theologian Brother Michael, and exhausted physician Matthew Bartholomew (ostensibly for "relaxation").
Once in York, they discover that the codicil may never have existed and that several Zouche's executors have died mysteriously. Then Radford dies, shortly after claiming to have found the codicil. Matt sets out to learn who killed his friend, and succeeds. I, unfortunately, didn't care. Matt belongs to Cambridge, and I feel a bit lost when he roams too far from home. Gregory needed too much exposition to introduce all the new characters and settings, and yet many the characters remained indistinguishable and the situations confusing. Mystery in the Minster entertained me, particularly the final action scenes, but didn't stick in my mind. It's worth reading if, like me, you're a bit obsessive about reading whole series in order. The casual Susannah Gregory fan can probably give it a miss.