Sunday, February 14, 2016
The Black Book
The Black Book succeeds as a novel but fails as a mystery. I didn't find any of the interlocking mysteries (the attack on his DS Brian Holmes, the murder of the chef at Holmes's favorite Elvis-themed restaurant, and the cold case surrounding a hotel fire) Rebus solved particularly satisfactory. I found Rebus's personal life (he's crashing on the sofa of his own apartment because his girlfriend has kicked him out and he's sublet the apartment to students; then his estranged brother appears looking for a place to stay) to be more coherently plotted. Despite its weaknesses, I enjoyed The Black Book, but I recommend it more as an installment in a series. If you're reading books individually, you can probably skip this one.