Sunday, December 11, 2016
Island of Vice: Theodore Roosevelt's Doomed Quest to Clean Up Sin-Loving New York
What do you think of when someone mentions Theodore Roosevelt? The Bully Pulpit? The charge up San Juan Hill? Trust-busting? His cowboy years in the Dakotas? That's the myth, and the reality, but it's incomplete. Roosevelt was an upper-crust socialite and, when you get right down to it, a bit of a snob and a prude. Island of Vice covers the two years Roosevelt spent as New York's Police Commissioner, during which he fought to protect New Yorkers from sin and booze. Spoiler alert - sin and booze won. Roosevelt's anti-alcohol crusade (understandable when you realize that his brother Elliot died from alcoholism shortly before Teddy became Commissioner) fell hardest on the working class whose day of leisure - Sunday - was now the day when the bars were closed. As for vice, well, New York passed a law allowing alcohol sales in "hotels" so bars slapped together a few tiny rooms upstairs, ushering in a new era of hot-sheet hotels which rented by the hour. Eventually human nature and squabbling on the Board of Commissioners did Teddy in…until the campaign experience he gained made him McKinley's Vice President and, after McKinley's assassination, the youngest President in US history. Island of Vice is a fascinating look at two turbulent years in Roosevelt's and New York City's history, and adds another layer to TR's public persona.